Medical decisions and patient rights: Autonomy versus well-being

In today's world, patients are playing an increasingly active role in the decision-making process regarding their treatment. Patient autonomy and patient rights have become key aspects of healthcare. Why is patient autonomy important, what rights do patients have and how do these two elements affect their wellbeing?

Patient autonomy - what is it?

Patient autonomy means that each person has the right to be fully informed about their condition. This includes both an explanation of the diagnosis and information about the treatment options available. For healthcare-related websites, this means providing content that helps patients understand their health situation and talk to their doctors about the options available.

Another important aspect is that the patient has the right to understand his/her condition. This means that the content provided to him/her should be written in a simple and accessible way so that the patient can easily understand the information about his/her illness, diagnosis and treatment plan.

Patient autonomy also gives the patient the right to choose. This means that the patient has the opportunity to decide whether to accept the proposed treatment or to seek alternatives. Doctors should provide patients with information on different treatment options.

The key role of the right to information

The right to information is a fundamental aspect of patient autonomy. Patients have the right to full and comprehensible information about their health, diagnosis, available treatment options and potential side effects. Access to this knowledge allows patients to make more informed decisions about their treatment.

Doctors have a moral and ethical duty to provide accurate information to the patient. They should explain the diagnosis and treatment plan in an understandable way, avoiding medical jargon. The patient should also have the opportunity to ask questions and get clear answers.

The patient has the right to participate in the treatment decision-making process. Doctors should present different treatment options and the patient should be able to choose and co-determine their treatment.

The right to information is an integral part of healthcare that allows patients to better understand their health and actively participate in the treatment process. It also builds trust between the patient and medical staff, which has a positive impact on the effectiveness of treatment and patient well-being.

Consent to treatment

The patient's right to consent to proposed treatment or to refuse it is the foundation of healthcare based on respect for autonomy. It is the patient, who is the expert on his or her body, who has the final word in making decisions about his or her health. This is not only an ethical belief, but also a right regulated in many jurisdictions.

Consent to treatment is a key point on the road to personalised medical care. The patient has the right to know the full spectrum of available treatment options. Doctors are obliged to provide the patient with understandable information that will enable him or her to make an informed decision.

However, it is worth emphasising that the patient's consent is not a unilateral act. It is also the doctor's responsibility to ensure that the information provided to the patient is clear and understandable. Doctors have a duty to talk to the patient, to explain the potential benefits and risks of the treatment and to answer questions that may arise from the patient's side.

Considering well-being

Considering patient welfare is an extremely sensitive and important aspect in healthcare. While patient autonomy gives patients the right to make decisions about their treatment, doctors have a moral and ethical obligation to look after their wellbeing. This does not mean that autonomy is overlooked, but that the patient's health status always remains at the centre of attention.

Doctors are trained to assess which treatment options are best for a particular patient, taking into account not only the medical aspects but also the patient's overall life situation. There are situations where a patient may make a decision that seems beneficial to them, but may negatively affect their health or life. In such cases, doctors try to communicate these concerns and propose alternative solutions.

It is worth understanding that doctors do not act with the intention of imposing their will on the patient, but with concern for their health and well-being. Medical decisions are not black and white and each case is individual. An open and frank conversation between patient and doctor is important in the decision-making process. It is dialogue and mutual understanding that form the basis of effective healthcare.

Conflicts and dispute resolution

Conflicts and dispute resolution are an important aspect in the context of medical decisions and patient rights. Patient autonomy, i.e. the patient's right to make decisions about his or her own health, can sometimes conflict with concern for the patient's welfare. In such situations, where the interests of both parties appear to conflict, there is a need to find a compromise and a solution that takes into account both the patient's autonomy and his or her health.

It is worth noting that these conflicts are not uncommon in the medical world. They may arise from differences in religious, ethical or cultural beliefs between the patient and the medical team. Sometimes the patient may refuse certain treatment procedures or therapies that the doctor considers necessary, leading to an impasse.

It is worth stressing that the aim of dispute resolution is not to impose a specific decision on the patient, but to find a solution that respects the patient's autonomy while not jeopardising his or her health. It is a complex process that requires a lot of discussion, but the aim is to provide the best care to the patient, respecting their rights and values.


Poland's largest database of patient organisations. Use the search engine and check information on associations and foundations directing their help to the sick and their families.